Who Is a Jew? Contesting the Identity Crisis

Who Is a Jew? Contesting the Identity Crisis
By
James Scott Trimm

In recent years I have noticed an identity crisis among many Torah-seeking believers. Some have developed a fear—or even an aversion—toward embracing a Jewish identity. Instead, they prefer terms like “Israelite,” “Ephraimite,” or “House of Israel.” Behind this hesitation lies a common claim: that the word Jew (Yehudi) only applies to one tribe (Judah), or at most the three tribes of Judah, Benjamin, and Levi. According to this reasoning, the Ten Tribes and even Gentile proselytes to Torah and Messiah should never be called “Jews.”

This idea is not only historically mistaken, but also undermines the very restoration of Nazarene Judaism that YHWH is working in our day.

I myself came out of Rabbinic Judaism. When I accepted Yeshua as the Jewish Messiah, I did not leave Judaism to embrace some foreign religion. I remained a Jew, because Yeshua is the Messiah of Judaism, and His original followers were a sect of Judaism known as the Nazarenes (Netzarim). Our task is not to invent an Ephraimite alternative or some new hybrid faith, but to restore that ancient Jewish sect of Nazarene Judaism.

The Word “Jew” and the Ten Tribes

The Scriptures themselves use the term Jew far more broadly than just one tribe.

Take the Book of Tobit. Tobit was a faithful man from the tribe of Naphtali, carried away in the Assyrian exile (Tobit 1:1–2). He continued to bring his tithes and offerings to the priests in Jerusalem, keeping the Torah faithfully (Tobit 1:3–8). Later in the story, his people—exiles of the Northern Kingdom—are explicitly called “Jews”:

“And they and all the Jews who were in Nineveh rejoiced with great joy…”
(Tobit 11:17 HRV)

So here we have members of the Ten Tribes, in exile, faithfully serving YHWH—and they are called “Jews.”

We see the same in the Book of Esther. After the deliverance of Purim, we are told:

“And many from among the peoples of the land, became Jews: for the fear of the Jews had fallen upon them.”
(Esther 8:17 HRV)

Here Gentiles themselves “became Jews” by joining themselves to the Jewish people and their faith.

Sha’ul (Paul) echoes this reality. He calls his readers “formerly Gentiles” (Eph. 2:11; 1 Cor. 12:2), implying that they too had joined Israel—and in the broad sense, had “become Jews.”

Judah’s Faith and the Rise of “Judaism”

After the kingdom split, the Northern Kingdom (Ephraim/Israel) rebelled. They rejected the Davidic king, the Aaronic priesthood, and the Temple, establishing their own counterfeit religion (1 Kings 12).

But Judah, though imperfect, remained tethered to the true faith. Hosea says:

“Ephraim has surrounded Me with lies,
and the house of Israel with deceit.
But Judah still walks with God…”
(Hosea 11:12)

Because Judah was the house that remained faithful, the true faith eventually came to be known as Judaism. Already by the time of the Maccabees, Jews were said to be those “who strove zealously on behalf of Judaism” (2 Macc. 2:21). Philo, Josephus, and Paul all use the term freely in the first century.

Paul—though from the tribe of Benjamin—calls himself a Jew (Acts 21:39; 22:3) and even insists in the present tense, “I am a Pharisee” (Acts 23:6). He refers to his own faith as “Judaism” (Gal. 1:13). Clearly, “Jew” had already become the umbrella identity for all who practiced the faith centered in Judah.

Messiah and the True Worshipers

Yeshua Himself confirmed this when He spoke with the Samaritan woman, an Ephraimite. She claimed Jacob as her father (John 4:12), yet Yeshua did not dispute her tribal lineage. Instead He told her plainly:

“You worship what you do not know;
we worship what we know,
because salvation is of the Jews.”
(John 4:22–23)

He did not say salvation was of Ephraim, nor of a “new religion,” but of the Jews who worship in spirit and in truth.

The Prophetic Future

The prophets are equally clear: the hope of Ephraim is not to establish a rival identity, but to be reunited with Judah.

• Ezekiel 37 speaks of the “two sticks”—Ephraim and Judah—becoming one in YHWH’s hand.
• Zechariah 8:23 envisions ten men (symbolic of the Ten Tribes) taking hold of the tzitzit of a Jew, saying, “Let us go with you, for we have heard that God is with you.”

And Paul’s teaching of the olive tree in Romans 11 drives it home: Ephraimite branches are grafted into Judah’s cultivated tree, drawing nourishment from Judah’s root. The warning is clear: do not boast against the natural branches.

Conclusion: Nazarene Judaism and Jewish Identity

The House of Judah is not a dried-up olive tree. It is the cultivated tree into which Ephraim and the nations are grafted. Judaism is not a “tribal religion,” but the one true faith once delivered to the set-apart ones (Eph. 4:5; Jude 1:3).

Yeshua did not come to start a new faith. He is the Messiah of Judaism. The original believers were not “Christians,” but Nazarenes, described by Jerome and Epiphanius as Torah-keeping Jews who accepted Yeshua as Messiah.

Therefore, to embrace Yeshua is not to abandon Jewish identity, but to restore it. Ephraimites and Gentiles who take hold of the covenant are not forming something apart from Judaism—they are becoming Jews in the truest, prophetic sense.

🙏 Support NazareneSpace

Friends, our community space makes this work possible—but our rent is due in just five days, and right now we don’t have what we need to cover it. If the teachings and resources we share have blessed you, would you prayerfully consider supporting us?

You can send a gift securely via PayPal to donations@wnae.org or give online here: nazarenespace.com/blog/donate

Every contribution, no matter the size, helps us keep this work going. Thank you for standing with us in restoring the ancient faith of the Nazarenes!

Share on Facebook

Tweet

Follow us